Let’s begin with some math: 5 groups have gained an NBA championship since 2020, the Los Angeles Lakers are one in all them, but they’re now on their third coach over that point span with the hiring of JJ Redick.
Frank Vogel gained a title, then bought fired. Darvin Ham made the convention finals, then bought fired. Now Redick parachutes in because the hot-shot rent as we hear ridiculous comparisons to Pat Riley and Steve Kerr and Eric Spoelstra. It is nearly too absurd to even chuckle.
Yeah, we get it. Redick is a great man. He appears and sounds sharp. The Riley comp, should you actually need to be this lazy, lands in your lap from a headshot standpoint, as does Kerr due to their comparable participant profiles and broadcasting backgrounds.
This is not to say Redick will not be a profitable coach. Or hell, even an all-time nice one. But when he’s, like these names above, he’ll be the exception. Not the rule. The rule is that the majority NBA coaches are tied nearly on to their rosters. They may get a little bit roughly out of the group they have been granted, however not a lot. The Lakers, who’ve employed and fired seven coaches since Phil Jackson left in 2012, aren’t alone in all the time considering they’ve managed to determine the exception.
To run down the checklist of coaches that have been presupposed to make a major distinction solely to fare, barring a roster enchancment, a lot the identical as their predecessor would take perpetually, however let us take a look at a couple of current examples.
The Hawks employed Quin Snyder to switch Nate McMillan — who, it is value noting, was largely the beneficiary of circumstance himself as Atlanta bought wholesome in 2021 simply as he was changing Lloyd Pierce after which went on to make a fluky, matchup-friendly playoff run — when it turned out that McMillan, with a couple of extra years of proof, wasn’t really in a position to carry a Hawks roster that may’t defend and is just too reliant on the person creation of an in any other case stagnant Trae Younger.
Snyder got here in with a modernized plan to play sooner and shoot extra 3s and everybody purchased into the time-honored phantasm {that a} glitzy big-name coach might obtain a distinct end result with the identical crew. Incorrect. Atlanta bought worse.
In Milwaukee, Doc Rivers was introduced in to switch Adrian Griffin, who was introduced in to switch Mike Budenholzer, who gained a championship two years earlier than his dismissal. Griffin was 30-13 when he bought canned and the Bucks completed the common season 17-19 below Rivers.
One cease on the teaching carousel earlier. Rivers was additionally tabbed because the man to enhance on what the Sixers have been in a position to do below Brett Brown, who by no means made it previous the second spherical. Two coaches later, the Sixers nonetheless have not made a convention closing.
Chauncey Billups supposedly spoke the identical level guard language as Damian Lillard, who now performs for Rivers. Steve Nash had the identical former-player clout and rapidly grew to become one thing of a joke.
Monty Williams was the man to steer Detroit into the long run, and he lasted all of 1 12 months. The Pistons are actually paying him $65 million NOT to educate the crew anymore. Humorous how Williams was an ideal coach in Phoenix and a horrible one in Detroit.
It is nearly all circumstantial. Take a look at Jason Kidd, who was as mocked as any current coach for a few of his ways in earlier stops, however now, in precept, simply bought the identical extension that McMillan did in Atlanta as a coach who simply occurred to be on the sideline when the celebs aligned. Kidd is just not a greater coach than Rick Carlisle, who additionally is not as precious as this conference-finals run the Pacers simply made would point out.
Carlisle’s Pacers bought the Bucks with out the companies of Giannis Anteokounmpo and, for 2 of the ultimate three video games, Damian Lillard within the first spherical, after which a ravaged Knicks crew that was one step from pulling individuals out of the stands to play within the second spherical.
In the meantime, Kidd bought Kyrie Irving as a mannequin citizen, one thing Nash by no means loved, and big additions on the commerce deadline. When Kidd makes the Finals with largely the identical Dallas crew that Carlisle was by no means in a position to lead that far, we will speak.
Till then, if the crew modifications for the higher, and the coach, in flip, magically will get higher, do the mathematics. Right now final 12 months, Joe Mazzulla was supposedly a nasty coach. Did he instantly turn into a championship one as a result of he found out when to name timeouts or as a result of he bought Jrue Vacation and Kristaps Porzingis?
Was Nick Nurse that a lot better than Dwane Casey, who actually gained Coach of the Yr the summer time he bought fired, or did he simply stumble into Kawhi Leonard?
Is Chris Finch, the man who put Rudy Gobert on the court docket in an apparent change scenario vs. Luka Doncic to lose a conference-final recreation, some form of savior or did he occur to be within the seat when Gobert got here in to ensure a top-flight protection and Anthony Edwards advanced right into a famous person?
Did the Knicks turn into a No. 2 seed as a result of they’re “A Thibs crew!” or as a result of they bought Jalen Brunson? Earlier than you reply, everybody realizes that Tom Thibodeau is an effective coach. That is not the purpose. The purpose is he went 78-76 over two seasons earlier than he bought Brunson and Josh Hart and Isaiah Hartenstein and Donte DiVincenzo and eventually OG Anunoby.
This is not meant to take something away from Mazzulla or Nurse or Finch or Thibodeau or every other NBA coach who is not Kerr or Spoesltra or Gregg Popovic. It goes with out saying that they are all extremely good, achieved and succesful basketball individuals. It is simply an incontrovertible fact that almost all of them, definitely over time, is not going to ship a bottom-line end result that deviates an considerable distance from the reasonable customary of the roster with which they’re working.
End result, by the best way, is the operative time period there. Coaches impression gamers and groups in all kinds of the way. It is about relationships and communication behind closed doorways. In reality, Redick told Taylor Rooks in 2022 that he appears at teaching “as a approach to assist” as he alluded to the interpersonal alternatives such a place can afford.
“I had so many individuals assist me in my profession,” Redick stated. “And never simply head coaches; assistant coaches, participant improvement individuals, they usually have such a precious place in my coronary heart and in my life. And I might like to be a type of individuals sometime.”
What Redick is speaking about, the relationships which can be cultivated by means of teaching, the impression one individual can have on one other, which is a really rewarding and fulfilling factor, is nice and all, however that is not what will get head coaches employed or fired. This is not highschool the place the job description contains the molding of younger males. Redick is not getting a $1,500 teaching stipend whereas additionally instructing third-period science.
No, he is reportedly getting north of $30 million over 4 years to do one factor: ship outcomes. Wins and losses. That is it. So let’s hold it proper there: The Lakers gained 47 video games final 12 months and misplaced within the first spherical. You possibly can level to Kerr, who nearly miraculously took the Warriors from 51 wins and a first-round defeat of their closing season below Mark Jackson to 67 wins and a championship in his first season on the helm (with largely the identical roster), however once more, that may be a once-in-a-lifetime exception.
That Warriors crew was being egregiously under-coached by Jackson. One might argue there has by no means been a extra ripe basketball scenario for a brand new coach to stroll in and turn into a direct hero with a whole offensive overhaul begging to be made.
Inform me, on a macro stage, what’s Redick going to take action otherwise than Ham? And we’re not speaking about Taurean Prince minutes. We’re speaking about issues that can really change the fortunes of the crew. Redick says LeBron goes to play off the ball extra and Anthony Davis will probably be utilized in a featured approach?
Wow. Cease site visitors. We have some revolutionary concepts right here! The Lakers have been making an attempt to play LeBron off the ball for years. It is why they introduced in Russell Westbrook for crying out loud. You recognize what the important thing to enjoying LeBron off the ball extra is? Discovering somebody higher than D’Angelo Russell to play on the ball. Not hiring JJ Redick.
Certainly, coaches aren’t employed and fired at such an absurd frequency as a result of there’s actually a lot distinction from one to the subsequent. The press releases will discuss commanding respect of the locker room and all that jazz, however in fact, coaches are simply the simplest variable to alter when issues aren’t going in addition to you’d hoped.
You possibly can’t simply up and alter gamers. There are contracts. And a wage cap. However coaches can all the time be swapped out and in, and so long as that is the case, groups just like the Lakers will proceed to package deal their “exercise” on the bench and attempt to promote it as precise progress on the court docket.
It is the front-office equal of that man who stands at half court docket dribbling the air out of the ball, wowing the much less discerning fan with an array of fancy maneuvers meant to distract you from the truth that in all this circle spinning, he hasn’t really moved any nearer to the aim.
In all chance, the Lakers are usually not any nearer to their aim of profitable a championship with Redick than they have been with Ham. They usually definitely weren’t any nearer with Ham than they have been with Vogel, who really gained the entire thing as a result of he had a two-way roster with a number of playmakers and dimension and defensive versatility (and since Anthony Davis bought to shoot midrange jumpers in a high-school fitness center, however that is inappropriate).
So here is what is going on to occur: The Lakers are both going to alter their roster considerably sufficient to really change their on-court fortunes, through which case Redick, and the oh-so-smart individuals who employed him, will probably be showered with reward, or they will not enhance the roster, and LeBron and Davis will not be as sturdy as they have been final 12 months, and Redick instantly will not look so shiny.
At which level, we’ll all begin speaking about who’s going to switch him.
Searching for extra NBA protection? John Gonzalez, Invoice Reiter, Ashley Nicole Moss and particular friends dive deep into the league’s largest storylines day by day on the Past the Arc podcast.
